Some of you may have seen this from my Instagram (because, frankly, I would not shut up about it) but here is a piece I wrote for last month’s Red magazine on recurrent miscarriage and best-laid plans. I thought I would re-share here for anyone who might have missed it, or who’s new to my site (hello!)…
When the plan doesn’t go to plan
What do you do when the plan doesn’t go to plan? When the picture of what you thought your life would look like has not so much been re-drawn, as scrunched up and thrown out, along with any notion of a template or timeline you had to go along with it.
It is a curious position to find yourself in if, like me, you’ve always been a planner; a careful curator of lists and fastidious follower of rules. Even as a child, I guarded my colouring books jealously from my younger brother and cousins and their marauding Crayolas. I would agree to share only on the condition they let me shade a small border inside the edges of the pictures first. An extra margin of error; a safety net etched in the precise colours of my choosing.
So it is with some irony that, aged 32, I find myself script-less; scribbling frantically, way outside of the lines. Having followed a well-worn formula, somehow managing to tick off steady job, house and marriage, a baby was meant to be next on the list.
There were many factors and permutations my husband Dan and I had considered before deciding we were ready for children: money, parental leave, childcare, the possibility it might take a while to conceive – or that we might not be able to conceive at all. That we might face recurrent miscarriages – four, in fact, in the space of 18 months, with no discernible medical reason, the most recent last June  – was most definitely not in the plan. It wasn’t even in the back-up plan. Neither was it in any of the pregnancy manuals. No one gives you a book called What To Expect When You’re No Longer Expecting. And if one miscarriage feels like a false start, lonely and acutely painful in itself, four feels like an almost impenetrable detour off our chosen route.
By contrast, when I first found out I was pregnant, in November 2016, after months of trying, waiting, not-quite-knowing, it felt like someone had handed me a map, the road unfurling before me: first midwife appointment, first scan date, due date, first birthday and so on.
I thought I would be a mother by now. Albeit, the exact details have been recalibrated with each miscarriage and subsequent pregnancy. First, I’d assumed we’d be planning for Christmas with an 18-month-old this year. Then, after losing that pregnancy one steel-cold Saturday last January, and conceiving again a few months later, this was supposed to be baby’s first Christmas. After that, we thought we might have an eight-month-old to buy presents for. Finally, we’d dared to hope I might still be pregnant this Christmas – eight months gone, marooned on the sofa, grateful to have got so far (and so fat).
Instead, another year, another Christmas, and my uterus is empty – emptied. Our nights remain unbroken, our soft furnishings un-mussed by small, sticky fingers. Just the two of us, not three.
There is nothing quite like the swooping, sickening rush of the irrevocable as you realise you are miscarrying. A dizzying sensation, almost like vertigo, as you see that small stream of palest rose pink, trickling and traitorous; knowing you are powerless to stop it, forced to watch your status as a mother ebbing away. Your hopes and dreams quite literally in the toilet.
No better – as has happened to us twice – is a ‘missed miscarriage’, when your body divulges no physical clues, deep in denial that the baby has died, instead leaving the news to a sonographer, who will pause just a fraction of a second too long, squinting at the screen, then frowning. A breath that seems to suck all the oxygen out of the room, before: ‘I’m so sorry, there is no heartbeat’.
I have had to hear those words four times now, because even on the occasions where I’d already started bleeding, they do a confirmation scan. Just seven words that atomise your plans, indiscriminately, short-term, long-term. A wicked magician’s trick, really. Just like that – poof! – you are no longer going back to the office once you’ve wiped away the ultrasound gel, instead there will be decisions about surgery, pills, or ‘expectant management’ (just waiting for the inevitable, basically). And paperwork – forms with grim titles like ‘sensitive disposal of pregnancy remains’ – more blood tests, and more leaflets, the same leaflets you already have in the basket by the phone at home from last time.
Once again – poof! – you’re on the outside of parenthood looking in.
Though, in a way, after one miscarriage, you never truly experience pregnancy the way another couple might – the way we did, that first time. While each new pregnancy still brings a small tiny tug of hope, we’ve never quite retrieved that pure, golden joy. The secret pride in each other, the almost giddy excitement, especially in those early days when no one else even knew we were trying for a family, apart from my mum and a couple of close friends.
We talked about names for our baby a lot back then. Whole car journeys would go by, challenging each other to think of increasingly absurd combinations. Names of Newcastle United players for Dan (which I’d veto) and Forties actresses for me (which he’d veto).
A large part of the sorrow we both feel now, stems from the loss of that innocence, I think. I mourn knowing I will never be able to tell Dan I am pregnant, test stick clutched proudly in my hand, and have him simply kiss me and smile. Instead, for us it is all matter-of-fact; a string of wait-and-seeing and ‘not getting our hopes up’, with the added complication of having to arrange appointments at the clinic, who monitor me more closely now when I am pregnant, with fortnightly scans. There is no more talk of ‘when the baby comes’. Instead, it is a grim waiting game, holding our breath between appointments, focused only on seeing those next few millimeters of growth, willing there to be a tiny, flickering heartbeat.
For other people, your baby lives and dies in a single sentence
What you feel after a miscarriage is a kind of grief, albeit you are often grieving something most people didn’t know existed in the first place. If you tell people at all, they generally only learn of your pregnancy once it is over – and so for them your baby lives and dies in a single sentence. There is no chance to get attached, it only ever exists for other people in a ghostly negative. This can mean it isn’t always easy for them to understand in the normal framework of loss.
But treating it as a bereavement is, I have found, the most useful thing friends and family can do for you. Not simply through saying ‘I’m so sorry’ or sending flowers (although these small acknowledgements do help) but by understanding that there is a pain there that may seem greater than the sum of its parts, that can’t be accounted for simply according to the number of cells or weeks of gestation. It’s about recognising that you have not only lost an 8-week old foetus, you have lost the baby that foetus would have become – and the toddler, the teenager, even the 20-something sheepishly boomeranging back home post-university. And it takes time to let them all go.
Dan and I are well-practised now in negotiating each other’s feeling after a loss. The biggest question is usually do we feel ready to try again (there’s no real medical reason you have to wait, once the bleeding’s stopped and you’ve done a pregnancy test that’s come up negative, confirming it really is all over, you’re good to go, physically at least). So far, we have been fairly in step, although I suspect he tends to be led by me more than he lets on, because, as he’s said many times, ‘it’s your body’.
After the first couple of losses, we simply felt determined to try again. After the third, we took time out for the suggested medical investigations. After the fourth – and with a clean bill of reproductive health – we couldn’t help but ask: ‘what if it never happens for us?’
It’s a frank and frightening question to introduce into your relationship. The sub-text being: Am I enough for you? Are you enough for me?
We have to be sanguine about the fact that after this many miscarriages in a row, the statistical likelihood of another is higher the normal. That said, our doctors say there is no reason we shouldn’t go on to have a healthy baby. As for exactly what we do next, because miscarriage is still a largely unwritten, unspoken experience, I don’t know what ‘the done thing is’ from here on in. And there is surprising power in that: a permission to shed some layers of expectation for how everything has to play out; a relinquishing of a little control.
There may be no guidebook for where we find ourselves now, no map to triangulate from, no manual and no script – yet there are also fewer self-limiting ‘shoulds’, ‘musts’, ‘best bets’ or ‘let’s be sensibles’.
With no option to trace the well-worn steps of other people, the only way through is to forge your own path, to breathe in deeply and listen to your own instincts, likes, fears, needs. A small point maybe, but I recently left my job as an editor on a newspaper to pursue a career as a writer, something I doubt I would have had the courage to do before – no maternity pay when you’re freelance, after all. I still don’t believe in ‘everything happens for a reason’ (please never say this to someone who loses a baby) but is it too much to hope that the unmaking of our best laid plans, can sometimes prove the making of us?
A version of this post was originally published in the January issue of Red magazine, 2019
thank you for continually sharing your experiences.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for keeping reading – it really does mean a lot. Jennie xx
The pain of recurrent miscarriage so eloquently written… It’s an incredibly cruel and tough time that you are going through and I’m sorry you are in this position. I hope you are managing to get the right kind of help and support to help you through this. Xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much for reading – and for being so supportive. Messages like this one really do mean the world to me. (And yes – I’m lucky to have had lots of support. I’ve done a bit of proper therapy this year, as well as my other ‘therapies’ of running, writing, reading and generally trying to be kind to myself). Jennie xx
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’ve just found your account and read this. You’ve stuck so many chords with my journey, completely relatable and just to know we aren’t alone makes it just a little more bearable to continue striving for our dream x
LikeLiked by 1 person
Hi Fay. Feeling ‘normal’ is so important isn’t it? That is a huge weight that has lifted for me, through writing about everything. It doesn’t mean it’s not still painful sometimes to be on the outside of the 2.4 family template looking in, but it does at least remove the illusion that you’re the only one in this position. And, as you say, it makes it all a little more bearable. Wishing you so much luck and strength. Jennie xxx
This is the first time I’ve ever read anything that comes close to expressing what I’ve gone through with my three miscarriages (now not pregnant, trying, losing hope).
THANK YOU for writing this. Thank you for being the first person to make me feel like I’m not alone. One day I hope I’m brave enough to share it.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You’re so welcome. And you’re definitely not alone. I’m so sorry for everything you’ve gone through – please don’t lose hope though. I know how frustrating it can be, just feeling as though you’re waiting – waiting to get pregnant, then waiting for something to go wrong/everything to be OK this time. Thinking of you, in solidarity. Jennie xxx
Thank you for writing this. I just experienced my third loss in a row and have not found many resources beyond forums. You are a talented writer and have a way with words – you express so profoundly the grief, the truth, the guilt, and the sadness of loss. I hope for you that you will experience a healthy and sustained pregnancy soon.
Hello, thank you so much for reading – and I’m so sorry you find yourself here. I found it equally difficult to find much beyond the forums after my miscarriages, which is why I started this blog, really. The forums can be comforting, but what I wanted more than anything was to hear from a real, identifiable person who was going through/had been through the same thing. Sending lots of love and strength to you. You really are not alone. Jennie xxx
Thank you so much for your blog. I’m writing from Italy, and can’t actually find any similar place here where to read about these feelings in Italian. Reading your words, which actually seem to come right out of my brain in a different language, makes me feel less of an alien… I had a missed miscarriage last November; my baby, which I feel was a baby boy, was only 8 weeks old the day we discovered “there was no heartbeat”, he had shown us his tiny heart beating just one week before… In only 8 weeks, he was able to change me so much that my life is currently divided in “before”, “during” and “after”, and sadly the “before” and “after” stages do not seem that interesting now as compared to the “during” and the “should-have-been-after”.
It was my first pregnancy, me and my husband had been trying to conceive for 18 months and finally, unexpectedly, we succeeded. I knew “miscarriage” happens a lot, I knew it could have happened to me too, and I tried not to be too enthusiastic; we only shared the news with a few people and always adding things like “we’re happy, but it’s sooo early”/”if everything goes well, ….”,etc., we were super careful in hiding our enthusiasm as much as we could, but all of this “realism” did not help me/us to suffer less when the worst actually happened.
I’ll be 37 in a few months, I still have had no period since my D&C 4 months ago, so, even if I’m scared to the bones, I can’t even start to try again.
Right now, I’m like “floating” through each day (not sure if the metaphor is clear enough…). I’m quite sure I will not be able to be deeply, truly, totally happy ever again, but I really hope that “hope” will come back into my life. It’s still so hard, and all the people around don’t actually seem to understand it can still be so painful. Your words really help me to understand that I’m not alone… I still have the picture of the “lucky stick” in a hidden folder of my smartphone, still a half-full blister of folic acid in my medication box, still my ultrasound scans somewhere hidden in a drawer, but I’m still not able to look at any of them. I hope my heart will heal somehow.
Thank you for sharing your story, and thanks for letting me share mine. I wish us both a brighter future.
Thank you for sharing your story so honestly. I am so sorry for your loss. For a couple of our miscarriages, we have seen the heartbeat a week or two beforehand, thudding away, only for there then to be no heartbeat at 8 weeks. It feels so cruel, I know, like you’ve been given a tiny flicker of hope, only to have it snatched away again. For what it’s worth, I believe your heart can heal – and that while you won’t feel exactly the same again, joy and hope do slowly start to come back. Wishing you so much luck for the future. Jennie xxx P.S. Do go back to your doctor if your period still hasn’t returned now after the D&C – and you’re worried – just to make sure all is OK. I don’t know what the advice in Italy is, but here you’re told to go back to your doctor if your period doesn’t come back after about 6-8 weeks, although it can be normal for it to take a while to return to a normal cycle.
Thank you so much for your comforting words, Jennie. I really appreciate them, and wish you all the best.
PS As for my period, it finally came back! I’m such an “homonal mess” (hypothyroid+hyperprolactinemia)…but – at least – kind of “function” again.
Sending a big hug from here 😉
Hello! I just stumbled across your blog after “googling” something else entirely. You so eloquently put into words the emotions and experiences I had following our 2 miscarriages. The first was a “chemical pregnancy” at about 7 weeks and the second wasn’t given a name, but I went in for my 12 week scan and they saw an embryo, but could not find the heartbeat. I elected to “wait for nature to take it’s course” both times and the second miscarriage took 3 months before my body finally gave up. I think that was the hardest part. We waited about 6 months after that before trying again as I wasn’t sure I could handle it a third time. The passage of time between the first pregnancy and waiting to try for a third time also placed me in the “advanced maternal age” category, which gave me more anxiety. I so wanted to speak with my mom during this time, but she had passed away a few years earlier. I kept wanting to ask her questions and compare experiences with her; but then I would remember that I’m adopted and our comparisons wouldn’t give any insight to my struggles, but I would have welcomed that support nontheless. The irony that my non-biologically related mother had adopted me because she was unable to conceive and now I was also struggling to conceive was not lost on me. I so wanted a biological child because I had never known anyone that “looked” like me or “had my nose”, etc. and I loved that about families who were biologically related. However, I cannot think of a mother who loved her child more than mine loved me and vice-versa; so I came to think of pregnancy in the same way that people speak about weddings; it’s a wonderful event, but it does not make the marriage. A person is no less married if they skip the party and go to the justice of the peace. The wedding does not make the marriage, nor does the pregnancy make the parent. Blessings to you.